Martin McGahan introduced Iain who gave us in his address an update on what is happening with the Motutapu Restoration Trust, a Trust that the Newmarket Rotary Club has had a long association with.
Martin prefaced Iain’s address by noting that the Rotary club of Newmarket been long engaged with Motutapu Island, becoming a party to the Motutapu 2040 program in 1991.
As part of that program club was allocated an area in Mullet bay on the island where the club undertook weeding pest eradication and replanting. That role has expanded over time to include involvement in the Motutapu Outdoor Education Trust, the Rotary Centennial walk, restoration of the Red Barn and the Reid Homestead.
Our club also helped rehabilitation of the Rotary Centennial after Cyclone Debbie caused it significant damage.
Iain’s address was titled “Trouble at Mill”. Although humorous the title accurately reflects the current position on the island which impacts on our own involvement in activities there,
in short since the Ngai Tai ki Tamaki Claims Settlement Act 2018 there has been a hiatus in the activities of the Motutapu restoration trust as the Ngai Tai Iwi seem to want to talk only to the Department of conservation and have ignored any attempts by the trust to meet and discuss the way forward so that the work done on the island is not wasted and can continue for the future.
There were many strands to Iain’s address including the withdrawal of Ateed participation in meetings between all parties which has led to a collapse of communication exacerbated by the Iwi's unwillingness to communicate or deal with anyone other than the Crown through the Department of Conservation.
Amongst other issues complicating matters there is the litigation between the Iwi and Department of conservation over the grant of concessions on each of Rangitoto and Motutapu for guided walks and tours over those distinct and unique landforms. The Iwi in short are seeking to promote their own economic interests over those that are in place presently so that they can “compete” with entities such as Fullers.
That litigation has traversed all three levels of New Zealand’s senior court structure and looks like engaging those courts for the foreseeable future. Especially if the Department of conservation reach decision regarding the grant of concessions that the Iwi does not agree with.
Issues are arising with the Iwi, in relation to farming operations conducted by the lessee of the island farm. Apparently the construction of an offal pit damaged a midden somewhere on the island. The Iwi has objected to planting of native plants again on the basis that the clearance of the areas to be planted creates damage again to historic sites. Even the removal of weeds using herbicides is the subject of objection for the same reason.
As a consequence the Motutapu Restoration Trust has stopped planting. This means that the 20,000 plants in the nursery are going to be wasted. This is causing upset and distress to the volunteers. A further consequence is weeds are now abundant causing damage there is the risk of pests such as rats mice and similar reintroducing themselves to the island has now through this clubs and other entities hard work free.
All that work undertaken by generations of members of this club are at risk.
The inability for the trust to do anything is meant funding has been lost for future activities. Private entities and individuals who previously funded the activities of the trust are seeing there is a hiatus and so funding is being withdrawn.
The purpose of Iains address was to pose a question which members will have to answer. Does the club continue to support the Trust and MOEC as we have in the past, do we limit our support to MOEC, and comments made by Iain suggest that the Iwi have their eyes on that facility, or do we stand back from our involvement with the island and refocus our activities into other directions, or something else.
So reflect on Iain's address and let the club know what direction the club should take.